Will COVID stimulus be the breakthrough carbon capture has been waiting for?

The relief bill includes an extension of the 45Q tax credit, which gives companies a tax break for capturing carbon..

When the U.S. Congress passed its omnibus spending and COVID relief bill last month, plenty of people noted that it had a surprising amount for environmentalists to celebrate. Among the topline climate provisions: significant limits on a potent greenhouse gas found in refrigerants, new funds for wind and solar development, and an extension of the 45Q tax credit, which gives companies a tax break for capturing carbon.

There’s no doubt carbon capture is an industry in need of a jump start. If the world is going to meet its goal to keep temperature rise under 2° Celsius compared to preindustrial levels, everyone from the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change to the International Energy Agency agrees the world must capture and store much more carbon than we currently do. According to the IEA, we probably need to capture between 10 percent and 20 percent of the roughly 35 billion metric tons of carbon we produce annually if we want to prevent the worst effects of climate change.

CORONAVIRUS IMPACT: ADDITIONAL COVERAGE
sarya.jpg

Sanjay Arya is the Director of Morningstar Indexes and leads the Global Index Group. He is responsible for business strategy, product development, and distribution of the indexes. In this capacity, Arya oversees research that supports methodologies underlying the indexes and works with clients to build partnerships to enhance the usage and applications of Morningstar Indexes.He started the Global Index Group in 2001 and has led the development of a broad suite of equity, bond, commodity and asset allocation indexes. Arya has made numerous presentations on index-related topics at professional conferences, meetings of professional organizations, and professional education programs. His opinions have been quoted in the industry and in trade publications, and he currently sits on the review board of the Journal of Indexes.Prior to his current position, he was the director of equity data analysis and has been with Morningstar for 16 years.Arya holds a bachelor's degree in chemical engineering, and has a master’s of business administration in finance from Cleveland State University. He holds the Chartered Financial Analyst (CFA) designation and is a member of the Investment Analysts Society of Chicago.

Sandra Timmermann is the Director of the MetLife Mature Market Institute. In this role, she is responsible for MetLife’s information and policy resource center for issues concerning aging, retirement, long-term care, and the mature market. She is a nationally recognized gerontologist with over 25 years of experience in the field of aging. Prior to joining MetLife in April 1997, Timmermann held senior staff positions with several national aging organizations, including the American Society on Aging, AARP, and SeniorNet. Earlier in her career, she worked with corporate clients as an account supervisor in public relations and marketing agencies.\n\nTimmermann writes the Financial Gerontology column for the Journal of Financial Service Professionals. She is a frequent speaker at conferences and seminars, such as World at Work, Mid-Sized Pension Management, American Society on Aging, and the International Society of Certified Employee Benefit Specialists, and has been interviewed by major media, including the Wall Street Journal and the New York Times. She serves on the Boards of Directors of the American Society on Aging, the National Alliance for Caregiving, and the Southwestern Connecticut Area Agency on Aging. In addition, she is Chair of the Business Forum on Aging and is listed in Who’s Who in America. Timmermann received a BA degree from the University of Colorado and MA and Ed.D. degrees from Columbia University.

Currently the world captures about 40 million tons a year — a mere tenth of 1 percent of our total annual emissions. The global carbon capture industry is so small, in fact, that the U.S., which has just a dozen commercial facilities working, is its undisputed leader.

Smokestack
.
Luke Sharrett/Bloomberg

There are many reasons why carbon capture hasn’t taken off, but the primary one is that it’s expensive, and for a long time there was no incentive for big emitters such as oil refineries or cement makers to invest in making the technology profitable. In theory, that changed in 2018, when Congress greatly expanded the 45Q tax credit to allow companies to deduct as much as $50 (up from $20) per metric ton of carbon captured and stored permanently underground.

But the expansion came with a catch: It applied only to projects that had begun construction by 2023.

Carbon capture projects are very complicated. According to the Carbon Capture Coalition (CCC), it takes about five years on average just to get permitting to begin construction.

You see the problem. In the two years since 45Q was expanded — with great expectations that it would inspire lots of new projects — none have launched. Brad Crabtree, director of CCC, said several dozen are in the development stage, but many of these are now at risk of being abandoned since COVID has depressed the oil and gas market.

So, Congress stepped in again. Not only did it extend the tax credit out to 2025, the funding bill also added about $2 billion to fund six projects to demonstrate real world operability of innovative new carbon capture technologies. Significantly, two of those are reserved for steel and cement plants, as opposed to utilities, where previous investments have led to big failures. Currently there’s only one steel plant in the world with carbon capture, in Abu Dhabi, and the first cement factory with carbon capture is set to be built in Norway.

What can taxpayers realistically hope to get from their investment? Crabtree said that it will be a good thing if roughly 30 new projects, nearly triple the country’s current capacity, become operational. While that won’t capture nearly enough carbon in the short run, it might be enough to nurture a struggling industry, much the way tax credits in the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009 helped accelerate wind and solar.

“The whole point of the credit is to prove the technology works and costs can be lowered so a virtuous circle of investing and building can begin,” Crabtree said. “We can then ramp up in 2035."