CPA firms will be in a great position to help their small-business clients with the latest round of the Paycheck Protection Program, according to Barry Melancon, president and CEO of the American Institute of CPAs.
Speaking during a virtual meeting Tuesday of the Accountants Club of America, Melancon described some of the new wrinkles in what’s being dubbed PPP 2.0 after accountants successfully helped their clients with the initial rounds of the PPP last year.
“Our profession was on the front line and I’m very proud of how our profession has been on that front line,” said Melancon. “It’s different than our medical professionals who are on the front line dealing with our health, but they were on the front line dealing with small-business health, being the trusted advisors, helping them find business model changes and transformations to survive, maybe new opportunities to acquire distressed businesses, how to apply and use government assistance programs that were out there, and how to keep employment up.”

He noted that one of the changes in the latest $284 billion round of funding is that it is supposed to provide additional support for minority-owned businesses.
“This last round that passed right before the end of the year, it clearly has some other attributes to it, more segmentation, different rules,” said Melancon. “For instance, for the hardest-hit segments like restaurants, bars and hotels, there is greater availability of cheap loans which convert to forgiveness at three and a half times average monthly payroll.”
It will also be easier for small businesses such as restaurants to meet the revenue decline test of 25 percent in the new round of the PPP. But these businesses, which provide a critical source of employment to large numbers of workers, will need the funding to survive this year and help with the economic recovery during the pandemic.
“I'm proud of the CPA profession,” said Melancon. “I think the vast majority of CPA firms have done a phenomenal job of being sort of at the proverbial bedside of small business, helping them through this particular process and being really focused on what is necessary in the environment.”
He acknowledged that there were problems with the PPP in its initial rounds, and the AICPA had to push for more clarification on the ever-changing guidance coming out from the Small Business Administration and the Treasury Department, in some cases providing some initial guidance itself.
“Being a protector against fraud and doing the right thing, those are hallmarks of the values of the CPA profession,” said Melancon. “Our voice was clear that the government needed to be willing to accept imperfections in the program, even some abuses, in order to move quickly. It was an intense, ‘time is of the essence,’ ‘critical for survival’ issue for small business. There have been some problems in the system, which we all knew when you set up what has amounted to the largest government support program of business in our nation's history. There were critics in that process about the SBA, the Treasury Department, even some in the banking community. But the fact of the matter is, collectively, it was a remarkable job to get very much needed funds to small business from a survivability perspective.”
CPAs dealing with the PPP faced many unanswered questions, which the AICPA helped address even before the government could. “We did a lot of work trying to answer those questions,” said Melancon. “In fact, we answered some of those questions where Treasury did not, or could not, act quick enough. Some of it we might have had to alter slightly when Treasury finally got around to it. Some of it, Treasury adopted directly on our side of our original conclusions. But it was all about getting the money into those small-business hands.”
Allyson is the founder of Women Who Tech, which brings together 10,000+ diverse engineers, entrepreneurs, startup founders, investors, and industry leaders who are transforming the world and inspiring change through technology. As founder, she has produced several Women Who Tech TeleSummits packed with the most inspiring tech changemakers, disruptors, and startup entrepreneurs, ranging from Arianna Huffington, founder of Huffington Post, to Rashmi Sinha, co-founder of SlideShare, acquired by LinkedIn.
In 2015, Allyson launched the Women Startup Challenge in partnership with Craig Newmark, founder of craigslist, the Craig Newmark Philanthropic Fund, and Craig Newmark Foundation, to help fund and showcase women-led startups focused on solving problems for people, businesses, and the planet. Since its inception, the Women Startup Challenge has launched four pitch competitions across the U.S. and one in Europe, with 1700+ applications and over $1 million raised in cash and prizes for women-led ventures.
Allyson is also the cofounder of Rad Campaign, one of the top web agencies that has helped hundreds of organizations, advocacy campaigns, and philanthropists build hard-hitting campaigns, compelling websites, and data visualizations focused on increasing advocacy, donations, and community engagement. Her campaigns have been recognized with several prestigious web awards and featured on several top media networks ranging from CNN to NPR to BuzzFeed, and the Daily Show with Jon Stewart.
Allyson has been named one of the “Most Influential Women in Tech” by Fast Company, a “Tech Titan” by the Washingtonian, and “one of the top 30 women entrepreneurs to follow on Twitter” by Forbes for her leadership roles in technology.
Craig Newmark is Web pioneer, philanthropist, and leading advocate on behalf of trustworthy journalism, voting rights, veterans and military families, and other civic causes. In 2017, he became a founding funder and executive committee member of the News Integrity Initiative, administered by the CUNY Graduate School of Journalism, which seeks to advance news literacy and increase trust in journalism.
In 2016, he created the Craig Newmark Foundation to promote investment in organizations that effectively serve their communities and drive broad civic engagement at the grassroots level. Amid growing concerns about the proliferation of “fake news” in the course of the presidential campaign, one of the foundation’s first donations went to the Poynter Institute to create the Craig Newmark Chair in Journalism Ethics. Newmark is widely credited for his leadership in promoting “news we can trust.”
After working at IBM as an engineer for nearly twenty years, Craig became a consultant to major firms like Charles Schwab, and in 1995 as the Internet was starting to take-off, he began curating a list of San Francisco arts and technology events he personally emailed to friends and colleagues. People were soon calling it "Craig's List,” and when Craig turned it into a company, he monetized it only minimally, opting for a business model that prioritized "doing well by doing good." Today more than 5 billion ads have been posted on the site, the vast majority for free. While Craig remains chairman of craigslist, he has not been involved in management since 2000. He continues to serve as a customer service rep so that he can stay connected to the community of craigslist users.
In 2012, Craig was inducted into the Internet Hall of Fame. He was named “Nerd-in-Residence” by the Department of Veterans Affairs Center for Innovation in 2013. In 2015, craigslist received an award from the FBI in recognition of its undisclosed cooperation with the Bureau in combatting human trafficking.
Craig serves on the board of directors of a range of nonprofits including: journalism organizations (Center for Public Integrity, Columbia Journalism Review, Poynter Foundation, Sunlight Foundation); veterans organizations (Blue Star Families, Iraq and Afghanistan Veterans of America, Vets In Tech); women’s groups (Girls Who Code, Women in Public Service Project) and consumer organizations (Consumers Union/Consumer Reports). In addition, he serves on the advisory boards of nearly twenty other nonprofit organizations including, DonorsChoose, EFF, New America Foundation, Voto Latino, Wikimedia Foundation, Women Who Tech, and many others.
Born in Morristown, New Jersey in 1952, Craig earned degrees in computer science from Case Western Reserve University. He lives in San Francisco and enjoys bird- and squirrel-watching, science fiction, TV, and Dad jokes.
Craig communicates regularly through his own blog at craigconnects.org and through Facebook, Twitter, LinkedIn, Medium, and HuffPost. He also travels the country speaking about issues and appearing on behalf of organizations he supports.
The AICPA also worked to get PPP loans into the hands of small businesses by partnering with financial technology companies. “The fact of the matter is, not all 6 million businesses had banking relationships, and nonexistent banking relationships made accessing some of that money difficult,” said Melancon. “The fintech world which we've partnered with to give an option to CPA firms is another way for people to access that. We felt that was very important.”
He sees CPA firms serving as a gateway to PPP funding similarly this year. The SBA is starting to offer microloans to minority-owned businesses through community banks and other financial institutions as it begins to roll out the latest funding. Melancon doubts the PPP funding will run out quickly this year, as it did shortly after the passage of the CARES Act last year. Congress had to appropriate more funding, but $138 billion was left over when the program expired and is being used as part of this year’s funding.
More government help
Along with the PPP, another provision of the latest coronavirus relief package includes an extension of the Employee Retention Tax Credit. However, there are changes there too, making it easier for businesses to both claim the ERTC and apply for PPP loans.
“In the original CARES Act, a small business could do one or the other," said Melancon. "They could do PPP or they could do the ERTC. The law retroactively into 2020 said that you could actually do both and changed the limit, so there’s a much higher amount for the credit as long as you use different payrolls. In other words, you can't use the same payroll dollars to qualify for forgiveness and for the credit. But basically most businesses had maybe two and a half months of payroll to get to loan forgiveness, and so there were other parts of the year where they could claim that credit.”
He predicts that in the next few weeks, the IRS will issue an amended version of the Form 941, the employer’s quarterly federal tax return, to allow small businesses to retroactively claim the ERTC for 2020 and claim the credit through June 30 of this year, as long as they meet the requirements under the new law.
Melancon expects to see further aid programs coming out of the incoming Biden administration and the new Congress, but he pointed out that with the narrowly divided margins in the House and Senate, moderates are likely to dominate in Congress and there will be more of a need for bipartisanship.
The AICPA worked on a bipartisan basis to get full deductibility of PPP expenses included in the latest stimulus package. “Tax deductibility of the payments was probably the most bipartisan issue that was being debated as we wrapped up 2020,” said Melancon. “We were big advocates. That was the intent of Congress, that those monies spent with PPP would be deductible. Treasury said no. They didn't want to do that for certain reasons unless Congress reaffirmed that in the legislative process, which Congress ultimately did.”
The “CPA Caucus” of accountants in Congress is shrinking this year with the retirement last year of two representatives, including the former caucus chair, Rep. Mike Conaway, R-Texas. Another member of the caucus, Rep. Collin Peterson, D-Minnesota, lost his re-election bid in November. But one new CPA was elected this year, Rep. Victoria Spartz, R-Indiana.
“We had a net loss of two,” said Melancon. “That is unfortunate.” The caucus, while bipartisan, can exert some influence in areas such as tax reform and economic policy, but Melancon admitted it is probably too small to have a disproportionate impact.
Recruiting questions
College enrollment in accounting programs is also down this year due to the pandemic, but Melancon pointed out that is true of other degree programs as well, while students hope to return to campus in the fall semester.
“I think you could pick any major and there is going to be a decline that's probably going to play out in those numbers in the 2020-2021 university academic year,” he said. “Overall enrollments are down 14 percent. That is going to be virtually everything, and so we’re not immune to that. The fact of the matter is that we have had record numbers of majors in accounting almost every year since about 1995 and 1996. We had a small decline in the last reported numbers, but it was actually still the second highest ever because it was coming off of the all-time record.”
The AICPA has been partnering with the National Association of State Boards of Accountancy on a CPA Evolution project to attract more students to the accounting profession by emphasizing more technology skills in the curriculum and the CPA Exam. “There is a shift to a technology background as opposed to pure accounting,” said Melancon. “CPA Evolution was to address that and head that off and to have a mechanism where we adjust some of the detail that someone needs to know, depending on whether they're studying accounting, auditing. tax or technology, but still have a core that is important in that process. I think the fight for human capital in the pipeline will be very intense. High schools will be very important. The shape of CPA firms with technology is changing. The entry-level positions are changing. The traditional pyramid shape will probably continue to evolve to a ‘fat middle’ organization. And if we were sitting together here in 2024 or 2025 — hopefully physically together, not virtually together — I think we would be talking about how intense the war for experience and talent has become in all size firms.”
