The Institute of Internal Auditors is giving corporate America only a modestly better grade on governance in 2020 compared to 2019, and any improvement is probably due to the coronavirus pandemic.
The IIA and the University of Tennessee released their second-annual American Corporate Governance Index on Wednesday, scoring companies at an average of B- (82) on a scale of 1-100. That’s only a slight improvement from a C+ (79) a year ago. But the score still falls short of what the IIA and UT’s Neal Corporate Governance Center consider ideal practices for ensuring corporate sustainability, a healthy culture, transparent and accurate disclosures, and effective policies and structures.
“Maybe the pandemic has helped corporate governance a little bit over the last year because it’s resulted in boards and management and internal audit having a lot more conversations around the risks the organization is facing,” IIA president and CEO Richard Chambers told Accounting Today. “We saw this too in our risk report when we saw better alignment in how management, the board and internal audit see risk in a company. What we’re seeing here is that overall there is what would I call a modest improvement. I don’t think going from a C+ to a B- is a dramatic improvement. There are still areas where we think some more work needs to be done. I think boards are still a bit too trusting. They don’t bring enough skepticism to their roles.”
Results of the ACGI indicate gains across the Index’s eight Guiding Principles of Corporate Governance. Compared with last year’s results, company size (revenue) and industry took on larger roles in explaining variations in ACGI scores. The results suggest that, during times of heightened risk like the current pandemic, companies in regulated industries such as financial services, transportation and utilities exhibit stronger governance.
Deb Smallwood, Senior Partner at Strategy Meets Action, a ReSource Pro Company, is widely recognized as an industry thought leader who is known for her “big strategic thinking with pragmatic approaches to transformation.” Deb challenges the status quo of insurance and influences the industry to reimage the business of insurance for the digital connected world.
Deb’s passion is to advise carriers and MGA’s to create transformation strategies and plans by bringing clarity to the possibilities of change and innovation. For over 30 years, Deb has helped hundreds of clients transform their businesses driving high business value and success. Deb’s deep expertise is commercial lines underwriting transformation and how best to leverage customer experience, digital enablement and transformational technologies and data.
Prior to launching Strategy Meets Action, Deb held a variety of leadership roles including VP of the insurance practice at Tower Group, Chief Transformation Officer (CIO) at Insurance Company of the West (ICW), Partner at KPMG LLP, and Head of Commercial Lines Application Development & Maintenance at Liberty Mutual.
Deb is often asked to contribute to major insurance publications and is also a frequent keynote speaker at leading industry conferences.
Edward Webb currently serves as BPM’s advisory partner, offering over 35 years of experience in consulting and financial management, including specific experience in transaction advisory services for both healthy and stressed companies. A published author and speaker, he currently leads the Corporate Finance Consulting Group at BPM and sits on the firm's Management Committee. He holds a doctorate in business administration with an emphasis in ownership transition from Temple University, as well as an MBA with a focus on finance from Indiana University. He was born and raised in suburban Philadelphia before moving his family to California. He may be reached at ewebb@bpmcpa.com.
John Beal is Senior Vice President, Analytics, Insurance, for LexisNexis Risk Solutions. He is responsible for leading the company’s insurance analytics and modeling products and services. With more than 20 years of experience in data and analytics across the insurance and financial services industries and market-leading innovations, Beal and his team develop incremental predictive uses of existing data and processes with a strong focus on developing personal and commercial lines credit-based loss models as well as new non-credit industry solutions. Prior to LexisNexis, Beal held key leadership roles at First Union National Bank in Charlotte, where he was Vice President, Credit and Market Analytics within the Quantitative Analysis Group, and at Citicorp Bankcard, where he served as Assistant Vice President, Credit Policy Department.
The most significant improvement on the index was a decline in the number of companies who scored a failing governance grade. In 2019, 10 percent of companies scored an F, compared with only 2 percent last year. As in the first year of the ACGI, the majority of companies scored in the B and C range of governance performance, with less than one-fifth earning an A-range performance.
“This is our second edition of our Corporate Governance Index,” said Chambers. “A little bit of history here: I had been for a number of years impressed by our Corporate Governance Index in South Africa. I kept talking about how we really needed to do the same kind of initiative for corporate governance here in the U.S. That’s how we ended up giving rise to the American Corporate Governance Index. Last year was our inaugural edition. It’s going to be something that I think will provide a real measure over time of the relative strength or weakness of corporate governance.”
The IIA’s South Africa branch has been producing annual Corporate Governance Index reports since 2013, often in partnership with educational institutions such as the University of South Africa and the University of Pretoria. “I travel regularly to South Africa to be part of their conferences and programs, and I was very impressed with the fact that a Corporate Governance Index there was so widely referred to and anticipated,” said Chambers. “That started us on the path to launch the American Corporate Governance Index.”
Chambers will be departing his job as head of the IIA at the end of March. The IIA announced this week that Anthony Pugliese, president and CEO of the California Society of CPAs, will be taking over from Chambers (see story). The two of them will be working together to ease the transition over the next two and a half months.
“I didn’t really know Anthony Pugliese well before he was selected by our board to become the new president and CEO, but he and I have had several opportunities to interact,” said Chambers. “We’ve had some early conversations. We’re planning some good quality transition time between now and March 31 when I step down officially and formally as the president and CEO. Anthony, I think, brings a tremendous amount of association management experience to this job. He’ll be the 10th president and CEO of the IIA, and I can tell you, being a student of the IIA’s history, that he will bring more association management experience to the role than any of his predecessors, so I’m very excited that he’s going to have the opportunity to come in and manage the organization in the future. I certainly am going to wish him well and do everything I can to help prepare him for the role.”
Chambers’ own plans for his career after the IIA are indefinite right now. “If you look back at my career path, since I finished my career in government almost 20 years ago, I have aligned myself with organizations that are advancing the internal audit profession, and who are making investments in the internal audit profession,” he said. “I spent time at the IIA and spent time with PwC’s internal audit practice, so as I look at what I might do in the future, I think I’m going to be attracted to a company or organization that is advancing and investing in the internal audit profession. I don’t know yet exactly what that’s going to look like. It’s still over two months before I step down, so I don’t want to get too far ahead of myself in making definitive plans.”
