Let’s end the debate: Automation will never replace accountants

A valued accountant is a holistic business advisor to clients, solving human problems that technology simply cannot — and will never be able to — solve on its own.

Automation has brought significant changes to the accounting profession over the last decade. While some tools have made accountants’ lives easier, others have chipped away at their roles as startups seek to disrupt a legacy industry. The tech companies that developed these tools have also created and perpetuated a false debate about whether automation will overtake the industry completely and make accountants irrelevant.

It’s time to end that debate. A valued accountant is a holistic business advisor to clients, solving human problems that technology simply cannot — and will never be able to — solve on its own.

The question should not be whether automation will take over accounting, but where its real value lies. This technology has an important role in upleveling accounting, but there are clear limitations for its use. ScaleFactor offers an example of these limitations and a cautionary tale. The startup promised to replace human accountants with software and AI, but it was mostly smoke and mirrors, with people doing much of the work behind the scenes. The irony was palpable.

No software stack can match the financial acumen, critical thinking and trusted counsel that a human advisor offers. That’s particularly true today, as valued accountants have become business partners, not just number crunchers. Where software is limited to evaluating concrete inputs, accountants also leverage their financial acumen, understanding of clients’ business goals and observations of communication subtleties like the inflection in a client’s voice to make decisions. This allows them to serve as advisors to their clients, whether by adjusting business models in real time, building balanced and inclusive teams, or managing employee wellbeing.

The COVID-19 pandemic has underscored the importance of this advisory role in the face of high-stakes decisions. As many businesses have navigated changing unemployment laws, federal aid initiatives and revenue loss over the past several months, accountants have stepped up. The accountants I’ve spoken with emphasize that their clients increasingly rely on them for much more than “numbers” problems, like payroll. They are solving the “people” problems that can make or break a business and its employees’ livelihoods, like hiring or conducting layoffs in the midst of a crisis. Accountants need technology to solve the former so they can focus on the latter.

CORONAVIRUS IMPACT: ADDITIONAL COVERAGE
sarya.jpg

Sanjay Arya is the Director of Morningstar Indexes and leads the Global Index Group. He is responsible for business strategy, product development, and distribution of the indexes. In this capacity, Arya oversees research that supports methodologies underlying the indexes and works with clients to build partnerships to enhance the usage and applications of Morningstar Indexes.He started the Global Index Group in 2001 and has led the development of a broad suite of equity, bond, commodity and asset allocation indexes. Arya has made numerous presentations on index-related topics at professional conferences, meetings of professional organizations, and professional education programs. His opinions have been quoted in the industry and in trade publications, and he currently sits on the review board of the Journal of Indexes.Prior to his current position, he was the director of equity data analysis and has been with Morningstar for 16 years.Arya holds a bachelor's degree in chemical engineering, and has a master’s of business administration in finance from Cleveland State University. He holds the Chartered Financial Analyst (CFA) designation and is a member of the Investment Analysts Society of Chicago.

Sandra Timmermann is the Director of the MetLife Mature Market Institute. In this role, she is responsible for MetLife’s information and policy resource center for issues concerning aging, retirement, long-term care, and the mature market. She is a nationally recognized gerontologist with over 25 years of experience in the field of aging. Prior to joining MetLife in April 1997, Timmermann held senior staff positions with several national aging organizations, including the American Society on Aging, AARP, and SeniorNet. Earlier in her career, she worked with corporate clients as an account supervisor in public relations and marketing agencies.\n\nTimmermann writes the Financial Gerontology column for the Journal of Financial Service Professionals. She is a frequent speaker at conferences and seminars, such as World at Work, Mid-Sized Pension Management, American Society on Aging, and the International Society of Certified Employee Benefit Specialists, and has been interviewed by major media, including the Wall Street Journal and the New York Times. She serves on the Boards of Directors of the American Society on Aging, the National Alliance for Caregiving, and the Southwestern Connecticut Area Agency on Aging. In addition, she is Chair of the Business Forum on Aging and is listed in Who’s Who in America. Timmermann received a BA degree from the University of Colorado and MA and Ed.D. degrees from Columbia University.

Empowering and supporting employees will become an increasingly important driver of business success, as studies continue to prove. Using software to automate repetitive processes gives accountants the freedom to focus on advising their clients through tough moments by leaning into their most human skills, like problem solving and relationship building.

Advertisement

Tech-driven tools and insights can’t replicate these skills, but they can enable them. As the transformation of industries like health care and manufacturing have shown, automation is most effective when used to save time, ensure compliance and improve accuracy by handling routine, tedious, time-intensive tasks. By using software to automate payroll, tax filings and payments, accountants can focus on their clients’ higher-level business challenges and opportunities. They can also more easily identify trends based on recent and historic data, then apply these insights to make recommendations informed by data.

This is tech at its best. At its worst, technology makes accountants’ jobs harder and can erode their clients’ trust. Software might generate recommendations based on broad generalizations, failing to account for a business’s nuanced situation or economic context. During the pandemic and ensuing recession, we’ve seen that much of the data and algorithms feeding into advanced business tools have been built for a world that no longer exists. They fall short of helping businesses solve the complex, intersectional problems they face in 2020 and beyond.

Accountants can add tremendous value in this new world by leaning into their advisory role. A strong accountant is pivotal to maintaining a client’s business, which in turn supports employees’ livelihoods and helps economic recovery. It’s good for accountants’ businesses, too: it’s estimated that practices providing advisory services can generate 50 percent more in monthly client revenue. Technology has a role to play, but only as a boost to the advising, problem-solving and business strategy accountants already do on a daily basis.

More Thought Leadership

For years, creating a standout piece of B2B content was already challenging enough. Now, with AI tools churning out articles, social posts, and even entire white papers in minutes, the market is swamped with new content every day. Buyers and senior decision-makers rarely have the time—or the patience—to sift through it all. In an AI-flooded world, any veneer of "quality" can seem suspect if readers sense it might be auto-generated.

The decline of traditional search marketing is becoming impossible to ignore. Not long ago, a robust SEO strategy served as the backbone of inbound lead generation, supplying a steady flow of site visitors and form fills. But as AI-driven search evolves, many businesses now watch their organic traffic vanish—sometimes dramatically—because search engines are surfacing direct answers or relying on large language models (LLMs) to summarize content, causing fewer clicks to reach content-rich websites and publishers.

AI-driven search is rewriting how buyers find answers, and it's forcing a major change in how we think about inbound.