Nothing you learn in school prepares you for your first audit. College students spend years learning about the concepts and mechanics of accounting, business and statistics, but you can’t really learn how to be a CPA until you put it into practice — which is why we have to work in the field before we can become a CPA, even if we’ve passed the CPA Exam. In-person training and on-the-job experience are crucial to the success of our youngest accountants.
This year completely changed the accounting profession as we knew it. Offices closed, businesses shuttered and CPAs all over the country turned their homes into home offices. In a profession so reliant on in-person interaction, we've found ways to readjust, but not without consequences. As firms begin preparing this month for the busy season, we need to look back at what we've learned about hiring, training and working in a pandemic so we can prepare for the new normal.
Dr. Selma Hepp is the chief economist at Cotality.
The Hazard HQ team provides real time updates on the impacts of natural hazards on property. From blazing wildfires in California to hurricanes along the Gulf and Atlantic coasts to even tropical cyclones and earthquakes worldwide, this global team keeps tabs on catastrophic activity. They release explanations of the probability of homes impacted, the kind of damage we foresee and the dollar value of losses. In addition, they provide expertise and guidance to the industry on how to be more resilient and help protect homes in the face of natural hazards.
President and CEO Jill Castilla led a 180-degree turnaround at Citizens Bank of Edmond through her approach to Fintech and social media. She changed the story of the Bank from one of near collapse and failure to one of great success and innovation. Jill has told the story of the turnaround at conferences nationwide and to 5,000+ people in various industries. Jill broke virtual radio silence through the power of social media by leading the bank from having no audience to more than 30,000 followers who engage with the Bank through Twitter, Facebook, YouTube and Instagram. Jill was named “Most Admired CEOs in Oklahoma"; “Most Innovative CEOs in Banking”; "Community Banker of the Year"; and "Most Powerful Women in Banking" in 2015. She ranks #1 on ICBA’s list of Twitter influencers. Citizens’ community appreciation event implemented by Jill, “Heard on Hurd,” had more than 100,000 attendees in 2015 and generated more than $2.4 million in economic activity. Jill previously served in the U.S. Army and Oklahoma Army National Guard as a construction and civil engineer. Prior to joining Citizens Bank, she was at the Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City and with a community bank in Minnesota. Her academic background includes a Master’s degree in Economics from the University of Oklahoma and she is a graduate of the University of Wisconsin-Madison’s Graduate School of Banking. Jill is a distinguished alumna of Hawaii Pacific University.
The pandemic has exacerbated fraud and we’ll face mounting pressure to identify financial fraud next year. We’ve already seen major cases, such as this year’s Wirecard and Luckin Coffee scandals, that will only continue to be exposed during a time of economic instability. There was already a learning curve associated with the lack of training at an education level involved with identifying and ferreting out fraud. This will only continue as new CPAs get less hands-on training.
In the immediate aftermath of the pandemic, companies slashed their budgets for consulting and advisory work. As a result, accounting and consulting firms have had to do damage control. Business Insider reports that KPMG laid off parts of its tax, audit and advisory staff, Accenture cut 5 percent of its workforce, and PwC paused all fall recruitment efforts.
Most layoffs skew toward junior or administrative employees, which has led senior auditors to take on more work and different kinds of work. This change in staffing has influenced the day-to-day work of more experienced employees in two ways. On one hand, they no longer have large teams with junior members to take on administrative tasks, bogging down employees in the grunt work. On the other hand, they no longer have to train these younger employees, opening up more time to do client work.
Training takes up a lot of time, but it's a crucial part of the workforce ecosystem. As entire offices went remote and companies trimmed their teams, we began missing out on in-office communication and in-person training, which can have long-term effects on our profession. It's easy to not feel the brunt of it at first; in fact, productivity and efficiency have gone up in the short term. However, we'll start to see a larger learning gap between new hires and more experienced accountants in the long term.
Another side effect of these layoffs is that the market for experienced CPAs is much more competitive. As businesses struggle with unpredictable cash flows, inefficiencies and new government policies and financial aid packages, the demand for seasoned financial talent has increased, and companies are fighting to hold onto their best performers who can work autonomously from home.
It's great to see so many adapting to the work-from-home environment, and cuts or delayed hiring may have been necessary for the profession to manage through the first wave of the pandemic. But as we enter phase two, we need to prepare for what 2021 and beyond will look like in this "new normal."
There's a big challenge we face with new-hire training, and it will be hard for new hires to be as effective if they can't work alongside their teams and learn in-person. Firms might be inclined to skip out on or limit hiring new talent this November. You could see demand for experienced hires go up because seasoned professionals can work more autonomously, while demand for new hires decreases as firms realize they are at a disadvantage in trying to train new employees effectively, even with the technology and collaboration tools that are available.
When COVID-19 changed the way we worked overnight, technology adoption was no longer a nice-to-have but a necessity. Gone were the days of relying on manual processes and side-by-side training, and the firms that were already technologically savvy have shined the most during this dark time. That's not to say technology can or will solve all our problems.
The firms that double down on a hybrid model of training — half remote and half in-person, following government guidelines — will be the most successful in this new normal. The virus will not magically disappear in the new year, so we need to further advance technology adoption that enhances CPA capabilities, such as utilizing remote learning and training capabilities, and shift from confirmation procedures that rely on mail or fax to electronic confirmations, which more effectively fit into the new normal of working from home.
We will need to get back to team-based in-person work and training at the client’s location, however. These last few months have proven that we might not have to do it as often as before the pandemic. But the future of CPA talent relies on side-by-side training and mentoring, especially if we expect new hires to get up to speed as quickly as they have in the past.
Nothing students learn in school will fully prepare them for their first audit — never mind finding fraud. We need to hire these young professionals and usher our firms into the "new normal," a world reliant on technology, combining in-person and online processes, and dedicated to the education and training of our youngest CPAs.
